Yes, this has probably been asked to death, and I'm sure there are some well-prepared spreadsheets/images around that can contribute to this (though I don't know where to find them..) I sincerely apologize for this 2630847th request you've probably seen, but here goes:

Pictured is an image of the small amount of anime I have. I've only watched maybe a third of these, so yes I know I'm way behind. What I'm asking, kindly, is that you anons recommend anime for me to watch/add to the list/YOU MUST WATCH, bumped against what I already have.

The criteria for recommendations? None, really, other than try to recommend aside from what I already have. See some anime and think "if you liked _____, try____"? Suggest it. Do like 20 MUST WATCH anime come to mind? Recommend it. I'm trying to increase my library, so I'm rather open to suggestions. If you wanna give a brief explanation of why you like it/are recommending it, go right ahead. In the end, I'm just looking for suggestions.