>>760312>most of the anime I liked last year end up on everyone's worst listsThat's because people on MAL and other sites follow the mainstream taste and ignore anything that doesn't immediately catch their eye.
Winter 2019: Watashi ni Tenshi* (You'll probably only like this if you like lolis), Endro, Kaguya-sama^, Ueno-san (This is lewd), The Promised Neverland^, Mob Psycho S2^
Spring 2019: Shingeki no Kyojin S3P2^, Mayonaka no Occult Koumuin*, Yatogame-chan^, Hitoribocchi, High Score Girl^
Summer 2019: Joshikousei no Mudazukai, Dumbbell, Kanata no Astra, Takagi-san S2^
Fall 2019: Beastars^, Africa no Salaryman, Babylon (Not finished yet),
And some shit that only a few other people on /a/ and myself enjoyed and I don't expect to have the same appeal to most people: Bermuda Triangle, Dimension High School, Maou-sama Retry, Given^ (This is BL), Special 7 (Also goes by Tokunana), Kabukicho Sherlock (Not finished)
I put an * next to everything that has an OVA/special episode and a ^ next to everything with previous or subsequent seasons.
As these are all just what I like, a lot of them probably don't look as appetizing to you, so just go through the synopsis and see if it's something you'd enjoy. Viewing a trailer might be better, too.
Hope you enjoy whatever you decide to watch, though.