>>2765936>Qshitter is Qshitter, and that guy posts Rei Q to piss people off. I do not, I just argue to understand things. I told the other anon I wouldn't keep this up but I'm gonna take you at your word when you say you're not the Q-poster to address something:
>Look, I'm not trying to make you angryI'm not angry because as I stated in an earlier post, I don't mind NGE discussion. but consider that /a/ is for discussion and /c/ is for images.
>For the record, both theories have merits.>I think occams razor favors the "it's not rei's soul in eva00" theory more than the "Rei I is in eva00" theory. I too believe both theories are possible but you're wrong about which one's more likely. 'Split-soul' requires less assumptions and the assumptions one has to make are things that are known to be possible in the show, not so with the other theory.
Split-soul theory requires a single assumption: That Rei's soul was split after Rei I's death. And we have some facts to back that possibility:
>Split souls are possible (Kyoko)>Shiji thinks that what lurks in Unit00 is like Rei, but not like the Rei he knows.>Ritsuko THINKS that whatever is on Unit00 is out to get her.No-soul theory has multiple problems:
>it requires the existense of proto 'dummy plug implementations' as you call them.>ignores that dummy what dummy plugs do is emulate pilots not replace Eva's souls.>if by Unit00's time the AI could replace a whole eva soul there would have been no need for pilots at all. The fact remains that they couldn't simulate a soul until very late in the game. Which is why pilots exist.>Because there isn't made a claim about what's in EVA00, we can only assume what is in it. Even nothing.I'm with you here but you need to address the above points if you think no-soul has more merit than split-soul.
(1/2 - Side issue Ritsuko post incomming)
