>>5791255Since potions won't win, I will say Lily, just because we haven't hit diminishing returns and we get a +2 vs a +1. If we find a dude in our battle class who is good a wizard gardening and can make it a +2, I am all for that next chance we get. Actually, Arty's area of expertise is still unknown on the character sheet, maybe she happens to be good at magic gardens.
>>5791243We might just have to agree to disagree for now. If the next class illuminates some things on how QM wants to treat it, I may change my opinion but as it stands, AK to me is just a tool. One that is used mostly by bad people, but that is because good people have been poisoned to it; we know objectively good people like Snape can and are capable of using it well and, in the end, that greasy fuck was a hero who even Dumbledore trusted almost implicitly.
