>>43777283Grileo's sprite lacks depth because the far legs are too obscured by the ones in front, and they aren't really shaded much more by the body. The legs feel tacked on as well without an obvious connection point. 2/5
Abzero's pretty nice, though it's pretty awkward how the tail has to bend unnaturally outwards just to fit in the box. There might be a better way to make it fit. 4/5
Smartish is a cool idea, but the shading is odd. The brain coral lacks a shade except around the very back edge, and the fin doesn't cast a clear shadow under it. On a smaller note, try to move the mouth pixels a few bits to the left so that it's mouth and lips aren't skewed off to the side. 3/5
Grussgu has a great design, but keep the shading consistent so that it's shining overhead, and try to attach the kelp on it to the back instead of having it rise up a bit behind it a little. 4/5
Pasuragu is also a real cutie, but the pineapple shell is lit as though the light source is off on the right, and it's weird.
