>>51985420No.
My favorite non fat pokegirl is probably Gardenia or Flannery, while my favorite fat one is Maylene, followed by Sabrina.
Thicc Flannery is really high tier, though. Gardenia... I can see thick thighs, and maybe even a bit of a tire, but, no. She's cutest while she's more trim-to-average.
On the flip side, more thin (but still /fit/) Maylene is still pretty good, but Sabrina needs that plushiness for me.
For me it's pretty inconsistent, and I imagine the various reasons I like particular pokegirls plays into why I like some thicc, some slim, or some either way.
I WILL say, that any of them in more billowy, loose, or form hiding clothing turning out to be thicc under that is a huge turn on. Odd conundrum for Erika. Erika I like more slim... but if she drops the kimono and is like BOOM then that's incredible too. But, JUST thicc Erika isn't as good. It's an odd mental surface to scrabble over with her.
I think the harshest case is Jasmine. Jasmine is probably the poke girl with the roughest ratio of how much I like them slim vs thicc. Thicc Jasmine is just kinda... wat?
Tl;dr There's no correlation for me
