>>54026154All ugly/dull and cartoonish goofyness is a bad approach
>>54027810The Cat line looks nice, but i'm not sure about the anchor theme, all design elements seem a bit forced, like you wanted to have a cat starter, it had to be water type so it is blue and ends up with an anchor slapped on its face so it has something else going on with the design. It does look good, maybe the middle stage needs to be redone, maybe the final stage would look good on all-fours. 7/10
The Fire Tortoise line is also nice, but the last evo ends up looking a bit goofy with how you deisgned the volcano shell, you should rework the design there, 6/10
I really like the grass chicken design, it's simple and properly done 9/10
>>54028174>>54028246They look decent, i'll rate when i see final forms
>>54028390I dont really like the grass line. I dont like the grass pants nor the thing that ends up on it's head, dont like the color combination nor the expression from last evo. It doesn't really feel like a starter line besides the first stage. 4/10
>>54028398These line on the other hand, looks amazing, my personal fav too, but i'd also say it doesn't feel like a starter pokemon. 8/10
>>54028410Looks decent but i don't like the last stage. I don't like clothing elements on pokemon even though some real pokemon have them, like machamp or cinderace, only if they are very subtle and organic
I feel it lacks charisma, and while this one actually feels like a starter, it doesn't feel like a fairy type, i'd just shift the design to make it a water/ice 5/10
