Domain changed to archive.palanq.win . Feb 14-25 still awaits import.
[170 / 18 / 39]

No.54800294 View ViewReplyOriginalReport
Out of the Pokémon games that most people usually consider the best (Emerald, Platinum, HGSS, BW2) which game has the fewest flaws, in your opinion? Here's my list of what I consider flaws in these games:

Emerald
>You cannot rematch Steven Stone. Once you defeat him it's over
>There's no improved rematches in the Pokemon League
>No good way to level up your Pokémon
>When the Rooftop Sale happens is completely random

Platinum
>You can't remove those annoying boulders from your Secret Base in single player mode
>Amity Square is cute, but it just feels like a test ground for the following Pokémon feature in HGSS. It makes Platinum feel inferior to HGSS in this regard

HGSS
>There's no room customization, something that GSC introduced
>some locations in Kanto were restored to their full size compared to GSC, but some others like Mt. Moon weren't

BW2
>No Original Dragon
>Route 10 and Challenger's Cave were removed for some reason
>You cannot battle against Hilbert/Hilda (it would've been cool and it would've mirrored the battle vs Red in GSC/HGSS)
>Badge Polishing was removed
>You can only battle N once per season

These are the problems/flaws that I see with these games. What problems do you have with these 4 games? Which ones has the fewest flaws in your opinion?