>Another girl who was involved with [Ein]Shine, called Tarah[note:AKA Shachimu; now Nanashi Mumei], interjects herself into the drama. She says she used to be friends with Ashley but chose Shine instead, despite Ashley telling her what he had done to her. She attempts to WK Shine, but it ends up just making her look delusional. Recently, there has been some speculation that she sock puppeted [in Reddit] and on PULL in an attempt to discredit the girls and defend Shine.
>Recently, it has come out that he had a sexual relationship with an underage girl in which he was abusive and manipulative. He also had other relationships with girls that showed he had a preference for young girls with little to no sexual experience. Through his Snapchat, he has flirted with fans regardless of their age, and has pursued relationships with underage girls, as seen in Ashley’s case.
