>>13360161The criteria shouldn't be how detailed it is, after all, most of those are lost once they turn into emotes.
There are two things that make a good wiggly:
1) How recognizable it is
People who have not seen the chuuba should be able to recognize the vtuber after seeing the wiggly.
2) How creative it is
The sad truth is that now that templates are available anyone can recolor a wiggly. What makes your wiggly stand out from the rest?
One of my favorite wigglies is this one
>>13233635 because it does something outside the norm while showing the person actually knows something about the chuuba he made it for. Be it a small reference
>>13331124 or a radical edit
>>13301859 the important part is that one thing you did to show you actually care for the person you made it for.
As high effort as the sloth wiggly might be, I don't believe it became a great wiggly until the idea to make it move at 1/3 the speed was added.
Ultimately the objective of the wiggly should be to get a smile out of the person you made it for.
Wigglycrafters should not focus on many small details to reproduce the chuuba design identically, but on that one big thing that will make it stand out from the rest.
Taho wigglies are the greatest wigglies not because of how similar they are to the models but because of the extra stuff he added and that must have been a pain in the ass to do.
